Penetrating neck trauma continues to be a challenging subset of trauma care. This area is loaded with potential high-risk injuries and controversies about the optimal management. The literature favors a more selective approach to these patients, however, the fundamental principles of resuscitation still apply because airway compromise and exsanguination are the greatest immediate life threats. This article reviews the medical literature on the diagnosis and management of these complex injuries.
– The Editor of Trauma Reports
Introduction
The management of penetrating neck trauma presents a significant challenge to emergency personnel. Penetrating injuries to the neck present a challenging diagnostic and therapeutic dilemma because the spectrum of injuries ranges from minor to acutely life threatening. Successful management requires a practical understanding of the anatomy of the neck and the tremendous number of vital structures in close proximity. A thorough diagnostic and management strategy must be implemented in the emergency department (ED) to avoid missing potentially devastating injuries. Optimal strategy remains controversial, and there remains substantial institutional variation.
Epidemiology
Although there has been a decrease of penetrating neck injury in the United States in the past years, it remains a significant public health concern.1 This is due to the epidemic numbers of firearm-related injuries from interpersonal violence that still occur, particularly in highly populated urban areas. Most injuries are secondary to stabbings or gunshot wounds. Penetrating neck trauma accounts for 5%-10 % of all traumatic injuries in some urban trauma centers.2-4 Most penetrating injuries to the neck involve zone II, which extends from the cricoid cartilage to the angle of the mandible. As with most penetrating trauma mechanisms, males are affected more commonly than females by approximately fourfold.2 Mortality from penetrating neck trauma ranges from 2% to 10%.2,3
In the neck, vascular structures are the important anatomical structure most often injured.2 Venous injuries occur more often than arterial injuries. The common carotid artery is the most common arterial injury, with the subclavian artery being the next most commonly injured.2 Laryngotracheal and esophageal injuries occur almost equally with esophageal injuries being less common.2,5
Historical Perspective
Historical accounts of penetrating neck injury date to antiquity. One of the first works involves an esophageal injury from a stab wound 5000 years ago.6 Ambrose Pare described the first repair of a cervical vascular injury.7 Both the common carotid artery and internal jugular vein were lacerated and subsequently ligated. The battlefield gave rise to many accounts and advances in diagnosis and management of penetrating neck trauma. During the Civil War, penetrating neck trauma management focused primarily on observation. Mortality rates were approximately 15%.8 World War I management also focused primarily on observation, although exploration and ligation became more prevalent. Mortality rates remained essentially unchanged. By World War II through the Vietnam conflict, mandatory exploration with vascular repair was the accepted practice.9 Although this strategy missed very few injuries, it resulted in numerous negative surgical explorations. Today’s modern diagnostic capabilities have given rise to new management strategies, some of which focus on nonoperative management following diagnostic testing or observation alone.
Etiology
The etiology of penetrating neck injuries can be divided into three categories: gunshots, stabbings, and miscellaneous. Each category has different predisposing factors and injury patterns. Gunshot wounds and other high-velocity injuries generally produce greater damage and thus are more likely to require surgical exploration. Injuries from gunshots and stabbings most often have a clear etiology, and their epidemiological patterns vary according to causal factors (e.g., crime rates, hunting accidents, military activity). Concomitant injury patterns obviously must be diagnosed and managed. The miscellaneous category represents a broad spectrum of injury by various other penetrating objects — from automobile glass secondary to car collisions to impalement from airborne objects. Associated injury patterns can be as broad and unpredictable as the mechanism of injury itself.
The pediatric patient with penetrating neck trauma represents a unique management challenge. This type of injury is uncommon in the pediatric population, but the potential injuries and complications can be devastating.10 Literature on diagnosis and management regarding the pediatric patient is also scant. One study demonstrated motor vehicle collisions to be the most common mechanism of injury at 32.2%. Gunshot wounds and animal bites followed at 22.8% and 12.9%, respectively.10 A specific mechanism of concern is penetrating neck injuries from air-guns because physicians and other personnel may mistakenly consider BB gun injuries as somewhat trivial. Significant injuries have been reported, including an expanding spinal hematoma.11 Mortality rates were similar to the adult population. Zone II injuries were most common, a fact also seen in the adult studies.10 Associated injury patterns remain very broad, depending upon the mechanism of trauma and whether the injury is isolated or associated with multiple injuries.
Pathophysiology
The pathophysiology of penetrating injury is relatively straightforward. Traditionally, gunshot wounds are divided into low-velocity weapons (< 1000 ft/sec) and high-velocity weapons (>2500 ft/sec).12,13 Low-velocity weapons, which includes most handguns, tend to cause direct vascular injury. High-velocity weapons (e.g., hunting rifles and assault rifles) cause cavitation or disruption of tissue well removed from the tract. Types of direct vascular injury include intimal flap (most common), (Figure 1) transection, laceration, puncture, arteriovenous fistula, and pseudoaneurysm (Figure 2).12 Types of indirect vascular trauma include spasm, external compression, mural contusion, and thrombosis.12 Although the ballistics may be relatively straight forward, the path of the bullet may be difficult to predict.
The injuries from stab wounds are directly related to the characteristics of the weapon used, although the path and depth of penetration are often difficult to predict. Apparently minor wounds may be associated with significant underlying injuries.
Anatomy
The anatomy of the neck is complex. There are many important structures in proximity to each other. Traditionally, the neck is divided into three zones for the management of penetrating trauma. (See Table 1 and Figure 3.) Zone I extends from the sternal notch to the cricoid cartilage. Injuries to zone I have the highest mortality due to associated injuries to intrathoracic structures (Figure 4).2 Zone II lies between the cricoid cartilage and the angle of the mandible. Zone II injuries are the most common. Zone III consists of the upper neck above the angle of the mandible to the base of the skull. Surgical exposure is difficult in zones I and III.
Another classification separates the neck into triangles. The sternocleidomastoid muscle is the anatomical landmark that divides the neck into anterior and posterior triangles.13 The anterior triangle lies between the anterior midline of the neck, the inferior aspect of the angle, and the anterior border of the sternocleidomastoid. The posterior triangle is bordered by the posterior aspect of the sternocleidomastoid, the middle third of the clavicle, and the anterior aspect of the trapezius. Injuries to the posterior triangle have a lower incidence of significant injuries than those to the anterior triangle.14
The fascial and muscle planes of the neck are extremely important in the evaluation of penetrating injuries. The platysma is a thin, broad muscle that originates from the deep fascia that covers the upper chest and inserts on the inferior aspect of the mandible.13 It is covered anteriorly by the superficial fascia and by the deep fascia posteriorly. Any violation of this muscle defines penetrating neck trauma and mandates surgical consultation. The deep fascial layers may help contain a hematoma. These fascial layers also may provide a route for spread of infection in case of injury, especially the pretracheal fascia, which connects to the anterior pericardium.2,4
Clinical Features of Penetrating Neck Trauma
Isolated penetrating neck injuries are uncommon. Penetrating neck injuries occur most often in the setting of multiple trauma.4 The presentation may range from relatively asymptomatic to dramatic and acutely life-threatening depending upon the structures involved. To avoid missing subtle findings, the search for injuries must be systematic. The history and physical examination should be directed to the areas of potential injury including vascular, laryngotracheal, esophageal, and neurological injuries.15
Vascular injuries occur in approximately 25% of patients with penetrating neck injuries.15-17 Exsanguination is the most common cause of immediate death after a vascular injury.17 Morbidity and mortality also result from hematomas compromising the airway, direct vascular injury with subsequent occlusion, and bullet embolization.17 Mortality from these injuries ranges from 5% to 50%.2,4,13,15 The clinical features of a vascular injury may be quite obvious, such as pulsatile bleeding or an expanding hematoma. These signs, believed to demonstrate a definite vascular injury, are referred to as “hard signs”.2,13 (See Table 2.) Vascular injuries also may present with subtle neurologic or pulse deficits, therefore, a rapid yet vigilant exam is necessary. Late complications include traumatic aneurysm and arteriovenous fistula.5
Laryngotracheal injuries complicate 10% of penetrating neck injuries.15,17 With penetrating trauma, these injuries are rarely occult.3 The most common signs and symptoms include dyspnea, stridor, dysphonia, hemoptysis, laryngeal tenderness, subcutaneous emphysema, and air bubbling from the wound.2,3,13,15 (See Table 3.) Any of the above findings mandate laryngoscopy.
Table 3. Clinical Features of Laryngotracheal Injury
|
• Hoarseness/ altered voice
• Anterior neck pain / tenderness
• Hemoptysis
• Stridor
• Subcutaneous emphysema / crepitance
• Deformity of neck landmarks
• Air bubbling from wound
|
Esophageal injury occurs less frequently than vascular or laryngotracheal injuries due to the relatively protected location of the esophagus.17 Some authors have noted dyspnea, hemoptysis, and air-bubbling through wounds as “hard signs” of aerodigestive tract injuries.18 Most esophageal injuries are associated with laryngotracheal injuries due to its location.5 Signs and symptoms of esophageal injury include dysphagia, oropharyngeal hemorrhage, nasogastric tube bleeding, subcutaneous emphysema, and resistance to movement of the neck. As with laryngotracheal injuries, crepitance is a strong indicator of esophageal injury.2,3,4,17-19 (See Table 4.) Despite these signs, esophageal injuries are the most commonly missed injuries in the neck.17,20 A delay in the diagnosis of these injuries increases mortality.13 An early diagnosis is required to prevent the development of mediastinitis due to para-esophageal contamination.
Table 4. Clinical Features of Esophageal Injury
|
• Dysphaglia
• Oral bleeding / nasogastric tube bleeding
• Anterior neck pain / tenderness
• Subcutaneous emphysema / crepitance
• Resistance to range of motion of the neck
|
Injuries to the nervous system include direct spinal cord injury, cranial nerve injury, peripheral nerve injury, and deficits in the central nervous system. Approximately 10% of patients with penetrating neck trauma will have an associated spinal cord or brachial plexus injury.13 The clinical presentation will depend upon the involved structure and the extent of the injury. In a recent study, almost 10% of asymptomatic patients with gunshot wounds to the trunk, head, or neck had spinal injuries.21 This percentage is much higher than had been reported in previous studies, and its results have been challenged.22,23 In Connell’s study, no spinal injuries were found among nonintoxicated patients with a normal neurological examination who had penetrating trauma.22 Also, the presence of a peripheral nerve injury should alert the evaluating personnel to the possibility of an associated arterial injury because most nerves are located close to large arteries.5
To read the rest of this article, please visit AHC Online.
References
1. Thompson EC, Porter JM, Fernandez LG. Pentrating neck trauma: An overview in management. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2002;60:918-923.
2. Duchynski RM. Neck injury. In: Ferrera PC, Colucciello SA, Marx JA, et al , eds. The Management of Trauma: An Emergency Medicine Approach. Philadelphia:Mosby 2001:218-231.
3. Baron BJ. Penetrating and blunt neck trauma. In: Tintinalli JE, Kelen GD, Stapczynski JS, eds. Emergency Medicine: A Comprehensive Study Guide. 6th Ed. New York:McGraw-Hill 2004:1590-1595.
4. Schaider J, Bailitz J. Neck trauma: Don’t put your neck on the line. Emerg Med Pract 1993;5(7).
5. Craducci B, Lowe RA, Dalsey W. Penetrating neck trauma: consensus and controversies. Ann Emerg Med 1986;15:208-215.
6. Breasted JH. The Edwin Smith Surgical Papyrus. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 1930.
7. Key G. The Apologie and Treatise of Ambroise Pare Containing the Voyages Made into Divers Places with Many Writings Upon Surgery. London, UK: Falcon Education Book;1957.
8. Otis GA. Medical and Surgical History of the War of Rebellion, Part 3, Vol 2: Surgical History. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office;1983.
9. Fogelman MJ, Stewart RD. Penetrating wounds of the neck. Am J Surg 1956; 91:581-93.
10. Abujamra L, Joseph MM. Penetrating neck injuries in children: A retrospective review. Pediatr Emerg Care 2003;19:308-313.
11. Keller JE, Hindman JW, Kidd JN, et al. Air-gun injuries: Initial evaluation and resultant morbidity. Amer Surg 2004;70(6):484-490.
12. Frykberg ER, Schinco MA. Peripheral vascular injury. In: Moore EE, Feliciano DV, Mattox KL, eds. Trauma. 5th Ed. New York: McGraw-Hill 2004:969-1003.
13. Britt LD, Peyser MB. Penetrating and blunt neck trauma. In:Moore EE, Feliciano DV, Mattox KL, eds. Trauma. 5th Ed. New York: McGraw-Hill 2004:445-458.
14. Siegrist B, Steeb G. Penetrating neck injuries. South Med J 2000; 93:567-570.
15. Kendall JL, Anglin D, Demetriades D. Penetrating neck trauma. Emerg Med Clin North Amer 1998;16:85-105.
16. Asensio JA, Valenzianio CP, Falcone RE, Grosh JD. Management of penetrating neck iInjuries: The controversy surrounding zone II injuries. Surg Clin North Am 1991;71:267-296.
17. Newton K. Neck trauma. In: Marx JA, Hockberger RS, Walls RM, eds. Rosen’s Emergency Medicine: Concepts and Clinical Practice. 5th Ed. Philadelphia: Mosby 2002:370-380.
18. Vassiliu P, Baker J, Henderson S, Alo K, Velmahos G, Demetriades D. Aerodigestive injuries of the neck. Amer Surg 2001;67:75-79.
19. Weigelt JA, Thal ER, Snyder WH, et al. Diagnosis of penetrating cervical esophageal injuries. Am J Surg 1987;154:619-622.
20. Demetriades D, Asensio JA, Valmahos G, Thai E. Complex problems in penetrating neck trauma. Surg Clin North Am 1996;76:661-683.
21. Klein Y, Cohn SM, Soffer D, et al. Spine injuries are common among asymptomatic patients after gunshot wounds. J Trauma 2005;58:833-836.
22. Connell RA, Graham CA, Munro PT. Is spinal immobilisation necessary for all patients sustaining isolated penetrating trauma? Injury 2003;34:912-914.
23. Rhee P, Martin M, Pleurad D, et al. Letter to editor. J Trauma 2005; 59:1033-1034.
Source: Trauma Reports, 11/06